The Starting Lineup – Fan Favorite Cookie Box

These aren't just cookies. They're the ones with a fan club.
We took your most-ordered, most-raved-about, most-can't-stop-thinking-about-it cookies and packed them into one legendary 6-pack.

The Starting Line-Up is for the real ones—the repeat buyers, the gift givers, the “I’ll take the usual” crowd.

🍪 One each of:

• Banana Pudding
• Reese’s Brownie
• Cookie Butter S’mores
• Strawberry Crunch
• Red Velvet Cookies & Cream
• Birthday Cake

📦 6-pack only – fixed lineup, no swaps (allergy exceptions only!)
💖 Fan-tested, cookie-lover approved
🚚 Ships nationwide or preorder for market pickup
✨ The box you reach for when you want the good stuff

No fluff. Just favorites.

💖 Why You'll Love This

• The Greatest Hits, All in One Box — No guessing, no FOMO. This box is the curated best-of — six fan-favorite flavors that have been ordered, re-ordered, and raved about by cookie lovers everywhere.
• Six Completely Different Flavor Experiences — From the nostalgic comfort of Banana Pudding to the indulgent richness of Reese’s Brownie and the festive joy of Birthday Cake — every cookie in this box hits differently.
• Perfect for Gifting — Whether it’s a birthday, a thank-you, or just because — this box makes an instant impression. It’s the gift that says “I actually put thought into this.”
• Great for Sharing (or Not) — Six distinct flavors means everyone gets their favorite — or you get to try all six yourself. We’re not judging.
• Artisan Small-Batch Quality — Every cookie in the box is handcrafted by Let’s Get Baked Artisan Desserts with real ingredients and serious craft — no shortcuts, no fillers, just exceptional cookies.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Can I swap out any of the cookies in the box?
The lineup is fixed — these six flavors were chosen because they’re the crowd favorites. However, if you have a serious allergy concern, reach out to us and we’ll do our best to accommodate.

How many cookies are in the box?
You get 6 cookies total — one of each flavor in the Starting Lineup.

Is this a good gift?
Absolutely. The Starting Lineup is one of our most gifted items — it’s thoughtful, delicious, and arrives ready to impress. No wrapping required.

Do they contain any allergens?
Yes — cookies in this box contain wheat, eggs, dairy, and soy. Some flavors may contain peanuts or tree nuts. They are made in a kitchen that handles all common allergens. Please review carefully if you have food allergies.

How should I store the cookies?
Store in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3–4 days, refrigerate for up to a week, or freeze for longer storage. Microwave individual cookies for 8–10 seconds to enjoy them warm.

Can I preorder for local market pickup?
Yes! Select the preorder for market pickup option at checkout. We’ll have your box ready and waiting for you.